Because apparently nightmares come with luxury price tags.
Listen, I love a good creepy doll, a disturbing horror movie, and a house that looks like something terrible happened there about 100 years ago, or today.
But some people take their love of horror to an entirely different tax bracket.
I’m talking about collectible dolls that cost more than my groceries, movie props that could probably pay a utility bill, and decorations that might actually make me afraid to walk through my own house at night.
And the worst part? I kind of want all of them. 😂
So, if you’re a serious horror collector, someone who celebrates Halloween 365 days a year, or just a person with questionable taste and an impressive disposable income, I’ve found eight creepy little treasures you need to see.
Fair warning: These are not your bargain-bin Halloween decorations. Some of these collectibles come with prices almost as terrifying as their faces.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a qualifying purchase through these links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.
1. Billy the Puppet From Saw: Would You Like to Play an Expensive Game?
There’s something particularly unsettling about a little man in a suit who rides a tricycle and wants to discuss your life choices.
And now you can bring him home!
This deluxe Billy the Puppet prop features sound and motion, because apparently having him sit silently in the corner wasn’t disturbing enough.
Imagine getting up for a glass of water at 2 a.m. and seeing this thing staring at you.
Absolutely not.
The price isn’t nice and neither is the puppet.
2. Lizzie Borden: An Axe, an Attitude, and Absolutely No Good Intentions
Some people decorate their homes with flowers, candles, and inspirational quotes.
Other people prefer a creepy doll holding a bloody hatchet.
No judgment. Well, maybe a little.
This handmade Lizzie Borden collectible features a black dress, wild-eyed expression, and an axe that suggests she’s not particularly interested in discussing her feelings.
She’s also a reminder that true crime and home decor can apparently share shelf space.
Personally, I’d be very careful about where I put her. I don’t need to wake up and discover she’s moved three feet closer to my bedroom.
3. Annabelle: The Doll That Needs Her Own Security Deposit
There are creepy dolls, and then there’s Annabelle.
You know, the doll that made an entire generation suspicious of children’s toys.
This collectible recreates the infamous doll from The Conjuring, complete with her unsettling expression, vintage clothing, and that innocent little face that absolutely nobody believes.
She’s the kind of decoration that makes guests ask whether they’re allowed to leave.
And the really disturbing part?
Someone will happily spend hundreds of dollars to bring her home.
I’d personally make her sign a lease.
4. The Leprechaun: He’s After Your Gold, and Apparently Your Paycheck
Forget rainbows, lucky charms, and little pots of gold.
This Leprechaun looks like he’d steal your jewelry, insult your family, and then ask why you don’t have anything more valuable.
The Ultimate Leprechaun Kickstarter Edition is a serious collectible for fans of the horror franchise.
And he’s not exactly inexpensive.
Which seems a little unfair, considering he’s supposed to be the one with all the gold.
At this price, he should arrive with a retirement account and excellent credit.
5. Slappy From Goosebumps: Childhood Trauma, Now in Collectible Form
If you grew up reading Goosebumps, you already know this little troublemaker.
Slappy was terrifying when I was younger, and I see absolutely no reason why bringing him into my house as an adult would improve the situation.
This full-size puppet prop is perfect for serious Goosebumps collectors and anyone who enjoys making their visitors deeply uncomfortable.
Imagine casually putting him in the guest bedroom.
“Make yourself at home! Oh, and don’t worry about Slappy. He usually stays where I leave him.”
Usually.
6. The Voodoo Forevermore Doll: I’m Not Touching That
Now THIS is the kind of doll that makes me question somebody’s decorating decisions.
With its stitched-up face, button-like eye, and distressed appearance, this thing looks like it was discovered in the basement of an abandoned house.
And somebody decided it belonged in a shopping cart.
I respect the commitment to creepy decor, but I’d have questions.
Where exactly are we displaying this?
Does it get its own chair?
And why do I feel like it already knows my name?
7. The Eery Porcelain Doll: She Looks Like She Knows Something
There’s something about old-fashioned porcelain dolls that has always bothered me.
Maybe it’s the glassy eyes. Maybe it’s the perfectly arranged hair. Or maybe it’s the fact that they always look like they’re waiting for everyone to go to sleep.
This Eery Porcelain Doll from the Morgue Collection has a cracked-looking face, vintage-style outfit, and the expression of someone who witnessed something terrible in 1897.
She’s beautifully disturbing.
And that’s exactly the problem.
I could see her displayed in a gothic reading room surrounded by antique books and candlelight.
I could also see myself covering her face with a towel before bedtime.
Both things can be true.
So, How Much Is Too Much to Spend on a Nightmare?
Here’s the thing. I completely understand collecting things you love.
Some people spend thousands on designer handbags, sports memorabilia, or fancy watches.
Others spend their money on terrifying dolls that look like they might crawl out of their display cases at night.
To each their own. 😂
These collectibles aren’t for everybody, and they definitely aren’t budget Halloween decorations. But for serious horror fans, they’re conversation pieces, movie memorabilia, and a way to bring a little bit of their favorite nightmare home.
Just make sure you’re comfortable with the price before you fall in love with one.
Now I want to know: Which one would you actually bring into your house, and which one would you refuse to sleep under the same roof with?
Personally, I think Annabelle and Art the Clown can stay wherever they are.
With love, nightmares, and a very reasonable fear of creepy dolls,
Mama J 💜
Featured products are from Abracadabra NYC. Prices and availability are subject to change. This article contains affiliate links that may earn me a commission on qualifying purchases.
Leave a Reply